Track papers across labs, topics, and trends.
Search papers, labs, and topics across Lattice.
This paper critically reviews the evolution of citizen journalism and user-generated content in online news media, highlighting a significant decline in audience participation over the past two decades. Despite the initial promise of democratization through active audience engagement, findings reveal that both audiences and journalists exhibit low interest and reluctance towards content creation, leading to a perception of citizen journalism as a failed innovation. The authors argue for a redefinition of audience participation as "mediatised participation," reflecting the complex dynamics between media companies, journalists, and the public.
Citizen journalism, once heralded as a democratizing force, is now viewed as a relic of the past, with audiences increasingly disengaged and journalists defending traditional roles.
The second generation of web tools shook the journalist profession approximately two decades ago with the proactive incorporation of audiences into the media. Citizen journalism and user-generated content arose as an object of interest due to the democratising value of participation attributed to them, with empowered citizens who could emulate the professional and institutional practises of journalists. However, difficulties soon came to the surface, and audience participation in news media began to be limited. Within this context, this article conducts a critical review of studies on audience participation in news media based on a systematic literature review. The results indicate that, in general, audiences showed low interest in the creation of informative content and that their participation has grown increasingly problematic. In addition, journalists are reticent as they defend their professional role above all else, while company strategies have prioritised making participation profitable. For this reason, the idea of citizen journalism that offers user-created content through the media appears to be a thing of the past, with many characteristics that could define it as a failed innovation. Therefore, the text concludes that audience participation in the media could be defined as mediatised participation.