Search papers, labs, and topics across Lattice.
This study conducts a subtask-oriented analysis of automatic mixing systems through three controlled listening experiments to evaluate the effectiveness of two-stage mixing approaches. The results reveal that while two-stage systems significantly outperform single-stage baselines, the transferability of full-mix models to intra-group mixing is inconsistent, and inappropriate grouping can lead to noticeable degradation in mix quality. These findings underscore the importance of separating local balance from global mix coordination in the design of automatic mixing systems.
Two-stage mixing systems can dramatically enhance audio quality, but their effectiveness hinges on proper task decomposition and model selection.
Automatic mixing transforms multitrack recordings into perceptually coherent, balanced, and aesthetically consistent mixes. In real-world production, this task is challenging due to large track counts, diverse instrumentation, and strong inter-track dependencies. Two-stage systems address this complexity by separating intra-group processing from inter-group mixing, yet it remains unclear whether their gains arise from stronger component models or from explicit task decomposition. We present a subtask-oriented analysis of automatic mixing through three controlled listening experiments. We investigate whether full-mix models transfer to intra-group mixing, whether downstream models compensate for grouping and loudness errors, and whether two-stage decomposition improves full-mix quality. Across three dense pop and rock excerpts, transfer differs between the evaluated models; inappropriate grouping causes clear downstream degradation, while altered loudness relationships have weaker and model-dependent effects. Both two-stage variants significantly outperform their corresponding single-stage baselines. These findings support explicit separation of local balance and global mix coordination as a useful design principle for automatic mixing. Code and audio examples are available online.
