Search papers, labs, and topics across Lattice.
This study benchmarks lightweight transformer models against traditional machine learning methods for on-device fault detection across three datasets, focusing on trade-offs in accuracy, latency, and model size. While lightweight transformers like TinyBERT-4L achieve competitive F1-scores, they incur significantly higher latency and model size compared to traditional methods, particularly on well-separated sensor data. The introduction of an adaptive inference pipeline demonstrates a promising approach to optimize performance, achieving high accuracy with reduced latency by intelligently routing predictions through quantized models.
Lightweight transformers can match traditional ML accuracy in fault detection but at a staggering cost of latency and model size, challenging their practicality in real-time applications.
On-device fault detection enables real-time diagnostics without cloud dependency, but deploying machine learning models on resource-constrained hardware demands careful tradeoffs between accuracy, latency, and model size. We present a benchmark comparing traditional ML methods (Random Forest, XGBoost, SVM, Logistic Regression) against lightweight transformer architectures (DistilBERT, TinyBERT-6L, TinyBERT-4L, MobileBERT) for binary fault detection across three public datasets: NASA C-MAPSS turbofan degradation, SECOM semiconductor manufacturing, and UCI AI4I 2020 predictive maintenance. We evaluate classification performance (F1-score, AUC), model size, and CPU inference latency, and further assess INT8 dynamic quantization and a two-stage adaptive inference pipeline. Our results reveal that on well-separated sensor data (C-MAPSS), lightweight transformers match traditional ML at 87.8% F1 but at 100x the model size and 9000x the latency. TinyBERT-4L emerges as the most deployment-friendly transformer at 55 MB and 18 ms CPU latency. INT8 quantization reduces size by 25% while preserving 86.9% F1. Our adaptive pipeline, routing 97.9% of predictions through a quantized triage model and only 2.1% to a larger expert, achieves 87.6% F1 at 19.5 ms average latency. On severely imbalanced datasets (SECOM, UCI-PM), both traditional and transformer methods struggle significantly, highlighting fundamental limitations of current approaches for extreme class imbalance in fault detection. All code is publicly available.
