Search papers, labs, and topics across Lattice.
The paper identifies a fragility in the Symile multimodal contrastive learning method, which uses multiplicative interactions to capture higher-order cross-modal dependencies, by showing that it treats all modalities symmetrically and is vulnerable to unreliable or misaligned modalities. To address this, they propose Gated Symile, which uses an attention-based gating mechanism to adapt modality contributions and suppress unreliable inputs. Experiments on synthetic and real-world trimodal datasets demonstrate that Gated Symile achieves higher retrieval accuracy than Symile and CLIP, highlighting the importance of gating for robust multimodal learning.
Multimodal models like Symile can appear to outperform CLIP even when a single unreliable modality silently corrupts the product terms, but a simple gating mechanism can fix this.
Multimodal contrastive learning is increasingly enriched by going beyond image-text pairs. Among recent contrastive methods, Symile is a strong approach for this challenge because its multiplicative interaction objective captures higher-order cross-modal dependence. Yet, we find that Symile treats all modalities symmetrically and does not explicitly model reliability differences, a limitation that becomes especially present in trimodal multiplicative interactions. In practice, modalities beyond image-text pairs can be misaligned, weakly informative, or missing, and treating them uniformly can silently degrade performance. This fragility can be hidden in the multiplicative interaction: Symile may outperform pairwise CLIP even if a single unreliable modality silently corrupts the product terms. We propose Gated Symile, a contrastive gating mechanism that adapts modality contributions on an attention-based, per-candidate basis. The gate suppresses unreliable inputs by interpolating embeddings toward learnable neutral directions and incorporating an explicit NULL option when reliable cross-modal alignment is unlikely. Across a controlled synthetic benchmark that uncovers this fragility and three real-world trimodal datasets for which such failures could be masked by averages, Gated Symile achieves higher top-1 retrieval accuracy than well-tuned Symile and CLIP models. More broadly, our results highlight gating as a step toward robust multimodal contrastive learning under imperfect and more than two modalities.
