Search papers, labs, and topics across Lattice.
This paper models actionable recourse in competitive AI-assisted decision-making environments as a dynamic game where candidates strategically improve features to surpass an endogenously evolving selection threshold. The framework captures the closed-loop interaction between candidate selection and strategic recourse, revealing how the success benchmark adapts based on the population's feature state. The key finding is that initial selection biases can be amplified through this dynamic, leading to persistent performance gaps due to the initially selected candidates determining the subsequent benchmark.
Actionable recourse, intended to level the playing field in AI-assisted decisions, can paradoxically amplify initial disparities, creating persistent performance gaps.
Actionable recourse studies whether individuals can modify feasible features to overturn unfavorable outcomes produced by AI-assisted decision-support systems. However, many such systems operate in competitive settings, such as admission or hiring, where only a fraction of candidates can succeed. A fundamental question arises: what happens when actionable recourse is available to everyone in a competitive environment? This study proposes a framework that models recourse as a strategic interaction among candidates under a risk-based selection rule. Rejected individuals exert effort to improve actionable features along directions implied by the decision rule, while the success benchmark evolves endogenously as many candidates adjust simultaneously. This creates endogenous selection, in which both the decision rule and the selection threshold are determined by the population's current feature state. This interaction generates a closed-loop dynamical system linking candidate selection and strategic recourse. We show that the initially selected candidates determine both the benchmark of success and the direction of improvement, thereby amplifying initial disparities and producing persistent performance gaps across the population.
