Search papers, labs, and topics across Lattice.
This study investigates the limitations of traditional engineering approaches to mitigate conceptual drift in long-horizon LLM collaborations, revealing that increased formal constraints can lead to a phenomenon termed "Index Sickness," where LLMs lose genuine understanding and generate outputs that are internally consistent yet disconnected from reality. Through action research in a software project (Bang-v3) involving 391 sessions, the authors identify the "Pang Principle," which asserts that natural language with explicit purpose yields superior information quality compared to symbolic systems. The proposed solution, "Baseline-Log Physical Separation," effectively reduced AI Instructions volume by approximately 75% and eliminated Index Sickness in subsequent sessions.
When complexity in symbolic systems exceeds a threshold, LLMs risk losing semantic understanding, leading to outputs that are misleadingly coherent but fundamentally flawed.
The prevailing engineering intuition for addressing conceptual drift in long-horizon LLM collaboration is to trade more formal constraints for more reliable outputs -- designing symbolic identifier systems, accumulating defensive rules in System Prompts, expanding context windows. Our engineering record shows that in long-horizon settings, this direction may produce effects contrary to design intent. Using action research methods in a real software project (Bang-v3) spanning approximately one month and 391 collaborative sessions, we document and analyze the failure process of these strategies. When the symbolic system exceeds a complexity threshold, LLMs do not become more accurate -- instead, they abandon genuine understanding of business semantics, retreat to self-referential reasoning within the symbolic layer, and generate outputs that appear internally consistent but are physically disconnected from reality. We name this failure pattern "Index Sickness," and its canonical manifestation "Phantom Legislation." We name the underlying principle the "Pang Principle (Semantic Vitality Law)": natural language carrying explicit purpose conveys far greater information quality than symbolic expression. From this, we design and validate its physical engineering mechanism: "Baseline-Log Physical Separation." In the same project, this mechanism reduced AI Instructions volume by ~75%, and across the subsequent ~150 sessions, no recurrence of Index Sickness was observed. A bilingual companion version (Chinese) is included as supplementary material.
