Search papers, labs, and topics across Lattice.
This paper investigates the carbon footprint of surveillance capitalism by comparing the network traffic and associated CO2e emissions of Twitter/X to Mastodon. They propose a framework linking surveillance processes to their material infrastructure and quantify the "corporate overhead" of X, defined as resource consumption not directly contributing to user experience. The study finds that X's corporate overhead represents a significant portion of its network traffic, establishing a lower bound for CO2e emissions attributable to for-profit activities unrelated to user experience.
Social media's relentless pursuit of profit through surveillance comes with a hidden environmental cost: Twitter/X's "corporate overhead" generates excess CO2 emissions compared to decentralized alternatives.
The business model of surveillance capitalism, premised on the extraction of behavioral data and its predictive potential for profit, relies on extensive material infrastructure. Such profit is typically driven by practices such as telemetry, user tracking, data analytics, secondary data uses, increased user engagement, and AI model training, as well as large-scale data storage systems that retain personal information for sale or reuse. This paper is motivated by the question: how much of the rising carbon impact of ICT can be attributed to this material infrastructure? Such an inquiry provides a foundation for quantifying the environmental costs of surveillance capitalism by proposing a conceptual framework and research direction that link processes of surveillance with their underlying material realities. To demonstrate the applicability of this framework, we examine the proportion of network traffic caused by surveillance capitalism processes through a comparative case study of a corporate social media platform, X/formerly Twitter, and a decentralized, non-commercial alternative, Mastodon. Our findings highlight the existence of corporate overhead: excess resource consumption driven by corporate social media practices, which is used as an initial proxy for the activities of surveillance capitalism. Our findings further demonstrate how the corporate overhead of X can be used to establish a lower bound in CO2e emissions attributable to for-profit activities that do not contribute to the user experience.
