Search papers, labs, and topics across Lattice.
The paper investigates systematic biases in age inference for Galactic archaeology, specifically concerning the age-metallicity relation (AMR) derived from spectroscopic surveys of subgiant stars. They identify a region in the observational quality parameter space (signal-to-noise ratio and parallax precision) where the inferred formation timescale exhibits a systematic offset of 0.5-1 Gyr relative to asteroseismic reference data, despite small statistical uncertainties. This finding challenges the assumption that increased data quality automatically leads to more accurate conclusions in Galactic archaeology.
Even with high-quality data, systematic biases in age inference can lead to stable but incorrect conclusions about the Milky Way's formation history, undermining the reliability of Galactic archaeology's key physical diagnostics.
Statistical inference in observational science typically relies on a fundamental assumption: as sample size increases and uncertainties decrease, the inferred results should converge to the true physical quantities. This assumption underpins the notion that big data lead to more reliable conclusions. In Galactic archaeology, stellar ages inferred from spectroscopic surveys are widely used to reconstruct the formation history of the Milky Way disk. The age metallicity relation (AMR) and its derived formation timescale are often regarded as key physical diagnostics of early disk evolution. This interpretation carries an implicit premise: that observational quality does not introduce systematic bias into age inference. Here we show that this premise may fail. Using a large sample of subgiant stars, we identify a region in the observational quality parameter space (signal-to-noise ratio and parallax precision) where the inferred formation timescale exhibits a systematic offset of 0.5-1 Gyr relative to an independent asteroseismic reference, while the statistical uncertainties remain small, thus producing a stable-but-wrong inference state.
