Search papers, labs, and topics across Lattice.
This study investigates the geographic distribution of AI research production across 781 European NUTS-3 regions from 2015-2024 using bibliometric data from Clarivate InCites. It calculates the Relative Specialization Index (RSI) and Relative Citation Impact (RCI) to identify regional AI research specializations. The key finding is that peripheral regions, especially in Eastern Europe and Spain, exhibit the highest relative AI specialization, despite major hubs leading in absolute volume, and that specialization does not correlate with citation impact.
Forget Silicon Valley, AI's secret sauce in Europe bubbles up from unexpected corners: Eastern Europe and Spain.
This study examines the geographical distribution of Artificial Intelligence (AI) research production across European regions at the NUTS-3 level for the period 2015-2024. Using bibliometric data from Clarivate InCites and the Citation Topics classification system, we analyze two hierarchical levels of thematic aggregation: Electrical Engineering, Electronics & Computer Science (Macro Citation Topic 4) and Artificial Intelligence & Machine Learning (Meso Citation Topic 4.61). We calculate the Relative Specialization Index (RSI) and Relative Citation Impact (RCI) for 781 NUTS-3 regions. While major metropolitan hubs such as Paris (IIle-de-France), Warszawa, and Madrid lead in absolute production volume, our findings reveal that peripheral regions, particularly from Eastern Europe and Spain, exhibit the highest levels of relative AI specialization. Notably, we find virtually no correlation between regional specialization and citation impact, identifying four distinct regional profiles: high-impact specialized regions (e.g., Granada, Jaen, Vilniaus), high-volume but low-impact regions (e.g., Bugas, several Polish regions), high-impact non-specialized regions, with Fyn (Denmark) standing out as a remarkable outlier achieving exceptional citation impact (RCI > 4) despite low specialization, and diversified portfolios with selective excellence (e.g., German regions). These results suggest that AI research represents a strategic opportunity for peripheral regions to develop competitive scientific niches, though achieving international visibility requires more than research volume alone.
