Track papers across labs, topics, and trends.
Search papers, labs, and topics across Lattice.
This study explores a semi-automated system that generates dialogue-based lessons using Large Language Models (LLMs) and Text-to-Speech (TTS) technology, integrating a human-in-the-loop workflow to enhance educational delivery. Through a quasi-experimental design involving 245 first-year high school students, the research found that dialogue TTS significantly improved comprehension and cognitive engagement compared to single-speaker TTS, while maintaining a comparable learning experience to instructor voice. The findings highlight a trade-off between the naturalness of audio and cognitive load, suggesting that while dialogue formats are preferred by students, they may introduce additional cognitive demands.
Dialogue-based TTS lessons not only enhance comprehension and engagement but also challenge the notion that single-speaker TTS is the most effective educational audio format.
This study proposes a semi-automated system for generating dialogue-based lessons using Large Language Models (LLMs) and Text-to-Speech (TTS) technology, and exploratorily examines its educational potential via a practical quasi-experiment. The system augments rather than replaces educators through a three-stage human-in-the-loop workflow (LLM-based slide/narration generation, educator review, automated audiovisual integration), and introduces a novel method for generating Expert-Novice dialogue narration based on cognitive apprenticeship theory. In a study of 245 first-year high school students who sequentially experienced three lesson formats (instructor voice, single-speaker TTS, dialogue TTS; content differed across sessions, limiting format/content separation), we conducted within-subject (Friedman test, N<=183) and repeated cross-sectional (Mann-Whitney U, N=229/206) analyses. TTS audio did not substantially degrade the learning experience versus instructor voice, supported by TOST equivalence testing. Dialogue TTS was significantly superior to single TTS in comprehension (p=.006, q=.025) and cognitive engagement (p=.019, q=.048); enjoyment was non-significant after FDR correction (q=.081) but reached significance after controlling for prior knowledge (proportional-odds model, OR=1.65, q=.025), and these advantages were not attributable to prior-knowledge imbalance. Conversely, single TTS was superior in audio naturalness (p<.001, q<.001, r=-.238), revealing a trade-off between dialogue's benefits and higher extraneous cognitive load. Dialogue format was preferred by 66.9% of learners as most enjoyable (p<.001). These results reflect a fixed-order design; replication is needed before generalizing them as effects of lesson format. This study provides a theoretical and empirical basis for the educational acceptability of TTS audio and for TTS lesson-format design.